Service Animals and the Subway
In light of the recent attack of a New York Subway passenger by an alleged service dog, there has been much discussion about what a service animal is and whether they are permitted on public transit. Service animals are commonly identified as dogs that are trained to perform a task or job for individuals with disabilities. The task or job must directly assist the person’s disability and these working dogs are protected under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). As a result, the dogs are permitted to ride the subway as long as they are harnessed or leashed. The ADA does not require service animals to wear a vest, ID tag, or identifying harness. Service dogs perform tasks such as alerting their owner of dangerous blood sugar levels, reminding their owner to take their medications and pulling manual wheelchairs.
Therapy Animals and the Subway
Conversely, therapy animals provide comfort and emotional support to their handlers. These animals can be dogs, cats, guinea pigs, llamas, pigs, rats, and more. They can reportedly provide benefits to their handler like lower blood pressure, reduced pain and anxiety, improved cardiovascular health and lessened depression, but the animal does not require any training. Under the provision of the ADA, emotional support, therapy, comfort, or companion animals are not considered service animals. Therefore, they do not fall under the protection of the act. In order to ride the subway they must follow the MTA’s provision that all pets must be in a carrier or bag and not disturb other passengers.
Difference Between a Service Animal and a Therapy Animal
Service and therapy animals are not one and the same. The difference between a service and therapy animal is that a service animal is trained to perform a task, while a therapy animal is untrained and meant to provide comfort. A service animal must be a dog, while a therapy animal can be any type of animal. For instance, an animal whose owner has an anxiety disorder, could be a service or therapy animal based on their training. If the animal is trained to detect an oncoming anxiety attack and take action, then it is classified as a service animal. If the animal is only to provide comfort, then it is a therapy animal.
On some occasions a customer traveling with a service animal may be asked by Police Officer or MTA representative, to describe the tasks the animal can perform. A customer who does not comply with the request may be asked to leave the transport facility, but this rarely happens.
Fake Service Dogs on the New York Subway
The New York Subway has cracked down on people who falsely claim their pets as service dogs in order to bring them onto the New York Subway. A significant number of alleged service dogs found on the Subway are not actually trained, or meet the ADA requirements. The abuse of the ADA law is very difficult to control and it is not clear how widespread the issue is. The government does not keep track of all service animals and several organizations have their own individual registrations. Phony service animal identification is available for sale online, where you can find just about every other kind of fake badge, vest, and sash. There is no national certification or registration process for a legitimate service animal and the MTA expects people to not take advantage of the ADA law.
People who falsely label their pet as a service animal harms the credibility of what a real service dog is. Fake service dogs did not go through proper training and it ruins it for people with legitimate disabilities. Actual service dogs are extensively trained to provide necessary services to those with disabilities.
Penalties for Making False Claims
The New York City Subway pressed NY State to pass laws making it illegal to falsely misrepresent your pet as a service animal. In 2017, Governor Andrew Cuomo signed a law which makes it unlawful to apply improper identifications designating a service or therapy dog. Violators can face a fine up to $100, up to 15 days of jail time, or both.
What Assistance Does a Service Animal Provide?
There are different types of jobs that the service dogs provide for people with a disability. These service dogs ensure that their owners are able to complete their day-to-day routines and activities without any issues or accidents. Most importantly, service dogs are trained to ensure their owner’s safety and health.
The most common type of service dog used in the NYC subway are guide dogs who lead the visually impaired and blind people around obstacles. Listed below are some general services a guide dog is trained to do, especially on the NYC Subway.
- Walk straight along the pavement, without distraction
- Safely guide the owner around the corners of the subway
- Open doors
- Assist with ascending and descending stairs
- Guide through large crowds
- Maneuver around the edge of the subway platform
- Avoid threats on the most dangerous NY Subway stations
ADA Requirements: Service Animals Identification
Identification of service dogs in NYC subway is not a requirement. ID cards and licenses for service animals can be requested through the MTA but they are voluntary as the ADA law forbids documentation requirements as a condition for entry. The individual must provide documentation of their disability and a physician statement explaining why a service animal is needed for travel. However, if the animal presents a threat to other riders the NYPD and MTA officials are permitted to remove the animal from the facility. The fine for bringing an unauthorized pet onto the subway is $25, but only 85 riders were fined last year.
Those with service animals can still face penalties despite the protection of the ADA. The owner in the recent subway dog attack was charged with assault and reckless endangerment, despite the dog being a legitimate service animal. The MTA Chairman also said the dog should have never been allowed on the subway, despite the NYPD verifying that this dog was a legitimate service dog. This sends mixed messages as to whether the MTA welcomes service animals on the subway despite ADA regulations.